How to choose the right
clutch for your car or pickup.
When choosing a
new clutch kit for your car or truck, there are several things that
you should consider. This Guide has been developed to help you go through
all the steps necessary to make the correct decision based on your specific
vehicle, taking into account the way the vehicle is used now and in
the future. Only through the careful consideration of all the relevant
factors can you come up with a decision that will give you a clutch
kit with the performance and life expectancy to be considered a true
value. In addition, this Guide covers only automotive applications such
as cars and pickups.
A vehicle can
be used in basically four ways:
* For personal
use
* For work (commercial) use
* For street performance
* For the race track
Most vehicles are
used in various combination's of the above as well. Keeping this in mind;
let’s look at the specifics of each type of use.
Personal use
In this case the
vehicle is being used as originally designed and is a daily driver.
The cost of maintenance and the ease of use are key considerations in
this case. No performance modifications are planned for.
Recommendation:
In this case, an aftermarket clutch kit with OE parts would be the best
value since these kits are usually less expensive than through a dealer.
Be sure to ask the seller if they are using OE components in the specific
kit you are buying. These kits come with a 12 month, 12,000 mile warranty.
All OE clutch parts are tested to one million cycles which is about
100,000 miles. If you are planning on keeping the car for a while, this
is definitely the way to go. If you are considering selling the car
soon, a cheaper kit made from low-cost foreign parts may be a possible
option. However, the most expensive part of a clutch job is the installation,
and if the bearing should squeal or fail, or the friction material wear
very quickly, then that less expensive clutch kit will end up costing
you more money, even in the short run.
Work or Commercial
use
Pickup trucks used
for work are often used to haul loads beyond the original design intent.
These trucks may also have been modified to increase the original horsepower
and torque ratings of the engine to meet these demands. If this is the
case, then a moderately upgraded clutch kit with long-life friction
materials is the way to go. It is important to let your clutch supplier
know how much any modifications have increased the horsepower and torque
ratings of the engine. Tire and exhaust modifications should be noted
as well. Try to be as accurate as possible so that the clutch is properly
matched to your truck. Also discuss any other issues like pulling trailers
or working off-road.
Recommendation:
A Stage 2 or Stage 3 clutch kit with either Kevlar or Carbotic buttons
is appropriate for moderately modified vehicles and would retain the
OE clutch pedal effort. For trucks that have been extensively modified,
a Stage 4 or 5 clutch kit may be required which would also include a
pressure plate with higher clamp loads and extreme duty ceramic buttons.
Do not assume that the higher the Stage of a clutch, the better it is
for your vehicle. Clutches need to be matched to the torque output and
specific vehicle use. A Stage 5 clutch in an unmodified truck will give
a hard clutch pedal and a very abrupt engagement. In addition, radically
increasing the torque capacity of the clutch means that the rest of
the drive-train needs to be upgraded as well; otherwise those parts
will fail prematurely and possibly cause safety issues.
A note about Dual-Mass
Flywheels in trucks: Until recently, most Diesel pickups came equipped
with a dual mass flywheel. The function of this flywheel was to provide
additional vibration damping due to the high compression diesel engine.
In these applications, many of the dual mass flywheels failed prematurely
either due to high loads put on the vehicle or poorly tuned engines.
All of these applications have solid flywheel conversion kits available
to convert them from a dual-mass flywheel to the more traditional solid
flywheel configuration. This is a great choice because the flywheel
can then be resurfaced in the future and the clutch kit can be upgraded
as well. Some additional vibration in the drive-train is to be expected
but is not considered harmful.
Street Performance
Recommendations
for Street Performance vehicles follow the same general guidelines as
the work truck above with the exception of pulling heavy loads. Cars
can have their chips modified, engines worked on, nitrous systems added,
exhaust systems modified, and flywheels lightened. All of these changes
affect the choice of clutch you would need. In lieu of having your car
dyno-tested for specific torque output (either at engine or at wheel),
it is very important to keep track of each component manufacturer’s
information regarding that part’s affect on horsepower and torque.
Keep your number as real as possible so that you don’t over-spec
the clutch kit.
Recommendation:
A moderately modified car, usually with a chip or exhaust mod only usually
fit into a Stage 2 clutch kit which allows the car to be a great daily
driver but stays with you when you get on it. This could either feature
a higher clamp load pressure plate with premium friction, or an OE pressure
plate with a Kevlar long-life friction material clutch disc. For more
highly modified vehicles, a Stage 3 through 5 is available with increase
clamp loads and specially designed clutch discs. Discuss your options
carefully with your clutch supplier and know what you are buying and
why.
A word about lightweight
flywheels: In addition to providing a mating surface for the clutch
disc and a mounting point for the pressure plate, a flywheel dissipates
heat and dampens the engine pulsations that are transmitted further
down the drive-train. Our recommendation is that unless the absolute
quickest shifts are of the upmost importance, we feel you are better
off with a new stock flywheel for clutch life and drive performance.
As you make the flywheel lighter when going from cast iron to steel
and then to aluminum, you increase the transmission of engine vibrations
throughout your vehicle (you shake in your seat) and more importantly
to your drive-train. This increased vibration will increase the wear
on the transmission and differential gears.
Caveat emptor (otherwise
known as buyer beware): If you are being sold a high performance clutch
for less than what a stock OE clutch kit goes for, you will not be happy.
OE clutch manufacturers have their tooling paid for by the vehicle manufacturers,
they run the longest production runs at the lowest cost using part number
specific tooling, acquire raw materials at the lowest cost, and do it
all while meeting the OE manufacturer’s durability and performance
standards. To think that you will get a higher performing clutch for
less money is really wishful thinking. A clutch can look okay while
being made from a cheaper grade of steel, uses steel parts that are
under-size, or has a lower grade of friction materials. If you search
the web, you will see many stories about unsatisfactory experiences
with clutches. That person either did not spec the clutch correctly
or bought one based only on price. A little time invested at the time
of purchase will be well worth it in the end.
Full Racing
At this point you
are concerned about one thing. Winning. Money is just the cost of doing
business on the track. So you have done your engineering, know your
vehicle, and know who the professionals are in the business you can
trust. At this level, we see multi-plate clutch packs with smaller diameters
for instantaneous response and high-end friction materials, lightened
high-strength alloys, and application specific release systems that
last a few races at best. Their value is judged solely by their contribution
to winning.
We hope you find
this guide helpful. If you have more detailed questions, send us an
email or give us a call.
|